The Magicians' Guild by Trudi Canavan, , available at Book Depository with free delivery worldwide. The Magician's Guild is a fantastic first book to begin The Black Magician Trilogy. I found it to be simply written, yet original, unpredictable, fast-paced and. The Magicians' Guild has ratings and reviews. Chelsea said: It's hollow, it goes on forever. My god It's full of tropes!I mean, se.


Author: Mabel O'Hara
Country: Namibia
Language: English
Genre: Education
Published: 28 May 2015
Pages: 733
PDF File Size: 22.63 Mb
ePub File Size: 39.11 Mb
ISBN: 746-4-56895-697-5
Downloads: 50253
Price: Free
Uploader: Mabel O'Hara


Sonea in particular is so untrusting that I find it hard to believe anyone would want to help her out.

The Magicians' Guild : The Black Magician Trilogy Book 1

Magicians guild to mention, the writing doesn't facilitate much emotional connection, being colourless, e. Magicians guild could have been strong.

Although young gang members gather to throw rocks at them, the magicians are protected by a magical shield—until Sonea, a young dwell, hurls a rock through their barrier and injures the magician Lord Fergun.

Fearing a rogue magician, the Guild begins searching for Sonea.

The Magicians' Guild (Black Magician Trilogy, book 1) by Trudi Canavan

Lords Dannyl and Rothen lead the search into the slums, worried that Sonea's increasingly uncontrolled magic will magicians guild her and those around magicians guild. Masters of the disciplines of magic, they know that no one can oppose them.


But their protective shield is not as impenetrable as they believe. Magicians guild Magician Trilogy - Rated: Guys like me are few, we live through deceit, we prey on trust, and we miss out on love.

The Magicians Guild by Trudi Canavan

Even the bravest have fears. K - English - Chapters: My thanks to sugarinthemorning for translating my story into Magicians guild under her pen name.

Lovecraft is the ability to show a full scale world and its history and culture through glimpses, allusions of past events or even architectural details or place names. This is magicians guild other writers have tried with varying levels of success, but one admirable thing Trudi Canavan manages is to eschew this technique in favour of a simple, character driven approach.

We know just what the other characters especially magicians guild principle protagonist Sonea know, indeed it wasn't until a good ways through the book that I found out the magicians guild of the city or country.

The Magicians’ Guild

This deft revelation of the world is something extremely well planned and really gives the reader a sense of scale, that this is a huge city people live in, and that the problems of individual characters are absolutely important to them, far more so than distant wars or political relations.

This also brings home to the reader the fact that magicians guild divide betwene rich and poor is quite extreme. The Rich may have imported items from distant lands or know the city's magicians guild, but the poor are simply concerned with dodging around the law and finding food, clothing and shelter.

One technique of world building magicians guild I do not appreciate, is Canavan's use of fantasy names for perfectly normal types of animals.

The Magicians' Guild by Trudi Canavan

While otherworldly creatures or artefacts specific to a culture should of course have their own names, to call a rat a ravi or sheep a reeba seems a rather cheap way of magicians guild mystery for its own sake. This also created an actual problem in the magicians guild of The Thieves, a shadowy, mafia type organization, since having them simply called spider or ox magicians guild been far more menacing, and have really emphasised the fact that The Thieves were using animalistic names, as well as missing out on the somewhat clumsy exposition necessary to understand what their names meant.


Stylistically in general I felt distinctly let down. This especially came across because Canavan's style is typified by long expository passages with magicians guild use of poetry or rhythm, she simply "says" what happens, often with need to explain minor details to the uninitiated reader. While this does have the advantage of making the reader intimately magicians guild with characters and their lives, it equally feels extremely disjointed in places, and is doubtless the chief reason I have seen several reviewers complain at her harping on insignificant details.


magicians guild A good stylist after all can convey information without seeming to convey it, but Canavan's plain, unornamented prose simply exist, meaning that details just get stated and that's it.

Another fact which contributes magicians guild this rather clumsy problem, is that of overall pacing.

Trudi Canavan | The Magicians’ Guild

The book features two principle plot threads, Sonea's attempts to avoid capture by what she perceives to be the evil magicians who routinely aide in kicking her and the other poor out of the city, and the Guild's often ponderous attempts to find Sonea and persuade her to accept training in magic.

The problem however, is that both of magicians guild plots take up two thirds of the novel. We know not the least because the second in the series is called The Novicethat Sonea will eventually join the Guild, thus we are presented with a huge amount of prevarication for its own sake.

While I do enjoy the way Canavan presents us with a group of Magicians divided in attitude towards the poor, and often somewhat removed from reality they felt very much like my own university's Philosophy departmentas well as slum dwellers magicians guild range from class solidarity to criminal syndicates, we have learnt magicians guild much everything about these groups in the first three or four chapters.

None of this served really too much purpose other than to pad out the overall narrative, and I found myself increasingly frustrated by the fact that neither plot appeared to be progressing or serving much purpose.